Tuesday, October 09, 2012

"Seize the Fire," by Laura Kinsale

The Chick: Olympia St. Leger, Princess of Oriens. Born and raised in exile in Britain, she's at the mercy of her evil uncle who seeks to marry her in order to secure the throne for himself.
The Rub: She has a plan to introduce democracy to Oriens to prevent further terrible monarchies, but to do that, she'll have to place her trust in the famous Captain Sheridan Drake - who has some dark secrets of his own.
Dream Casting: Kristen Schaal.

The Dude: Sheridan Drake. The famous war hero returns from the Navy to discover his deceased father bankrupted him and left his own fortune to be dispensed of at the discretion of his ex-mistress - who happens to hate Sheridan's guts.
The Rub: When an incredibly gullible princess sitting on a priceless jewel collection comes to him for help, he figures separating her from her gems will be easy pickings - but what if she separates him from his heart?
Dream Casting: Wes Bentley.

The Plot:

Sheridan: OMG I HATE THE NAVY, THE OCEAN, AND EVERYTHING! *tries to kill commander, trips an saves everyone*

England: HOORAY!

Olympia: Please help me save my country from the oppression of monarchy!

Sheridan: Please help myself to your jewels? Don't mind if I do!

Olympia: Hey, while you do that, why not introduce democracy to the sailors on our ship! *sparks mutiny* Why not reveal Sheridan's secret identity to a totally trustworthy sailor whom I've never met! *nearly gets shot* Why don't I start screeching about my jewels in front of some escaped convicts? *nearly gets raped*

Sheridan: Wow, you totally fell out of the Stupid Tree and hit every branch on the way down. It's a good thing you're hot.

Sheridan and Olympia: *stranded on desert Island*

Sheridan: Now I love you.

Sheridan and Olympia: *rescued and on board a ship*

Sheridan: ....and now I don't. Because I'm dark and damaged and stuff. Why don't I develop a mental illness, just to make things more interesting?

Olympia: Now it's time for me to fix you!

Plot: *Pirates* *White Slavers* *Possibly Gay Sultan BFFs*

Random Villains: *kidnap Olympia*

Olympia: Never mind. Back to being helpless until I'm rescued!

Sheridan: Hey look I'm suddenly rich now for no reason and your kingdom doesn't want you anymore, also for no reason. Let's hook up!

Olympia: HOORAY!

Romance Convention Checklist:

  • 1 Antihero Hero
  • 1 Evil Ex-Mistress
  • 1 Unscrupulous Servant
  • 1 Case of Body Issues
  • 1 Case of Daddy Issues
  • 1 Unfortunate Shipwreck
  • 1 Desert Island Romance
  • 1 Somewhat Incongruous Penguin
  • 1 Band of Pirates
  • 1 Case of Hand-Waved Plot-Propelling PTSD


The Word: I honestly never believed I would be typing the following words, but, I disliked a Laura Kinsale novel and thought it was horrible.

My safe, comforting worldview has been shattered. There's some things in this world that you think are just indisputable facts: Snow falls in winter. A full moon comes every 28 days. And Laura Kinsale novels are awesome.

That belief lasted until I read Seize the Fire, an inexplicably boring and haphazardly plotted mess of a novel.

Naval Captain Sheridan Drake is a famous war hero - entirely by accident. When his crazed attempt to murder his incompetent commanding officer during a sea battle results in him accidentally saving the fool's life and the lives of his shipmates (for reals), he is knighted and his name hailed across the nation as a brave selfless hero. Too bad he's completely broke - thanks to his apparently insane father who left him a demonically booby-trapped house while placing his fortune in a trust ruled by his manipulative ex-mistress, Julia.

Olympia is the princess of the tiny nation of Oriens, but she has lived her entire life in genteel exile in England after her despicable uncle murdered her parents. She has spent her twenty-four years of life stewing in self-loathing and French philosophy with her governess, Julia (yes, that Julia) and when she discovers her uncle is about to petition the Pope to marry her and seize the throne (consent-optional), she pays a call on the one man she knows will aid her in her plight - Captain Sheridan Drake. Surely, this glowing paragon of manhood will help escort her to Oriens to introduce democracy to her loyal subjects, or at the very least to Rome so that she can prevent her marriage by asking the Pope nicely.

Now, you might think Sheridan would be the harder character to like, as he immediately decides to fleece the plump little princess of her crown jewels and leave her in the lurch. Except not. As Sheridan rapidly comes to learn, Olympia is a breathtakingly stupid and obnoxiously pathetic heroine who is Literally Terrible at Everything except for crying, biting her fist in terror/misery/self-loathing, and almost getting Sheridan shot in the face. Poor Sheridan has to spend the next 500 pages of this massive book babysitting, protecting, getting waterboarded for (!), and Not Boning 160 crybaby pounds of narrative deadweight.

The sheer number of times Olympia almost gets Sheridan killed would be funny if she wasn't such a self-rightous TSTL dimwit about it. I hated Olympia - I thought her one of the worst and most useless heroines I've ever read. She never develops any spine, intelligence, or even any ambition beyond the incredibly shortsighted one of bestowing democracy upon everyone she meets. Once she has a protector her desire to free her people slips into the background. What does she want to do with her life? What does she do in her spare time? Who is she beyond this chubby, whinging, constantly complaining mess of a person? Her "kindness" and "purity" are supposed to be the Polysporin to Sheridan's Scraped Knee of Angst, but otherwise Sheridan seems to like her mainly because her breasts are the only things more impressive than her tear ducts.

Of course, most of the romantic progression involves Sheridan yo-yo'ing between Total Adoration Despite Being a Dark, Damaged Dude and treating Olympia like a turd in order to push her away from him because he's a Dark, Damaged Dude. You can imagine how quickly this becomes repetitive in a 583-page novel.

The thing is, the whole structure of the novel is a hot mess. The plotting is like a suitcase packed by an absentminded traveller - the type who forgets crucial items, only to shove them in at the last minute, one on top of the other, even though they don't really fit. The characterization of everyone except for Sheridan is atrocious, as their storylines are picked up and dropped, seemingly at random - Julia Plumb, for example, is depicted as a villainess even though she's only "on screen" for one chapter, in which she acts quite concerned and surprised. The only reason we even know she's a villainess is because Sheridan explicitly tells us how evil she is. Or Sheridan's father, who's mentioned in the initial chapters as a madman fascinated with pranks and booby traps, until his character and his impact on Sheridan is abruptly abandoned, never to be mentioned again except in passing.

In the last act of the novel we have, without any previous development of such plot points: the sudden insertion of severe and constant PTSD into our hero's character description, an entirely random violent past, an aristocratic dandy sidekick who appears 20 pages from the end and serves no narrative purpose whatsoever, a nonsensical misunderstanding that ensures the hero has a massive fortune by book's end, and an ambiguous Arabian Sultan who is apparently crazy in love with Sheridan until he's abruptly written out of the plot.

The thing is, Kinsale's written whackadoo plots before - evil cults, poisoned shellfish, kidnapped bulls, oral sex lessons from Catholic priests, white ninjas, and magic-sword-eating sharks, to name only a few. The thing is, in those cases she developed those ideas so that they made sense as one read them within the context of the story. She didn't just cram them in with no notice or precedent.

And it's just as likely that those plots appeared believable because they were populated by realistic, well-realized and sympathetic characters. The characters and their motivations and anguish felt real, so their adventures seemed real as well. In Seize the Fire, Sheridan's backstory is too vastly complicated to take very seriously (his previous positions include naval captain, harem slave, jewel thief, death goddess assassin, and gigolo - not making this up), and, as mentioned before, Olympia is such a pathetically incompetent twit that I had no empathy for her or her travails.

Laura Kinsale's writing is solid enough, but with such a randomly plotted storyline and dippy characters, there's just no reason to go on. Seize the Fire is all noise and no substance.
D+

10 comments:

  1. Oh my goodness, I can't decide whether I enjoyed the book or your review more. The book *was* a mess, it was an Everything Omelet with raspberry sauce. I completely see every point you make, every one of them valid. But I loved the book.

    Meanwhile, it's clear that I need to read more of Ms. Kinsale's work. What's that about kidnapped bulls and oral sex lessons from priests? Will have to search your other reviews.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The kidnapped bulls was her latest, LESSONS IN FRENCH, a rare example of a lighter Laura Kinsale romance. I quite enjoyed it.

      The Oral sex lessons from priests came from FOR MY LADY'S HEART, a fantastic medieval romance between an icy princess and a knight who's remained celibate for 13 years (!) for love of her.

      Kinsale is usually an expert chef at whipping emotional truth and resonance out of deliciously crazysauce stories. I might have enjoyed this one if Olympia hadn't been such an irritating moron.

      Delete
  2. Hello, happened upon your blog, well, this post specifically! I honestly can't remember every detail about STF since it's been years since I read it, but I do remember loving it. I find that with Kinsale, a person either really loves a book or really hates it. There usually isn't much of an in between. The one Laura Kinsale I remember not liking at all was The Prince of Midnight. That was one mess I could not see past to enjoy even a little bit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *GASP!* Begone, demon!

      Only kidding, but PRINCE OF MIDNIGHT is my faaaaave Kinsale. My ultimate ultimate fave, and like the best romance I have ever read ever.

      Ever.

      But I do get why people still like STF - a lot of people think that Olympia needs to be stupid at the beginning in order to add poignancy to how she grows up as the novel progresses. It just didn't click for me. Olympia was all faults - they never gave her any particular talents or interests or things she's genuinely GOOD at, so she just came across as this pathetic nobody.

      Also so many people like the penguin scene but it's like ONE CHAPTER.

      Delete
  3. Vorkosigrrl10:35 AM

    Oh, yeah . . . I knew there was a reason I only read this once. Then gave it away.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! Yes. I suppose every author has to write a dud now and then.

      Delete
  4. I don't always bother to click on you "dream casting" links, but after seeing your tweets, I had to click on these. It was well worth it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I honestly never thought I'd cast Kristen Schaal in any book but it was just so fitting here!

      Delete
  5. I've been reading your blog for over a month now. I can't remember if I have read any of the books you've reviewed but, I keep coming back because of the way you break a novel/story down is (extremely entertaining) actually very helpful. It is great to see a review of this type because (to me) it helps pin point things in my own writing that could be considered "needs more work". I enjoy your perspective and there's never a dull moment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! And that's the thing, there are just as many authors who can take tropes that I absolutely despise and spin them in a way that's amazing, so even my "hard and fast" rules don't always apply.

      Delete